Pearl Club

Best Midrange Bars in New York City

Recommendations/
New York City/
Bars/

1. Bayard's Ale House, New York City

Bayard'S Ale House Food

Bayard's is a landmark Irish pub in West Village. An excellent place for a beer after a long work week. Serves classic pub food - from bangers 'n' mash, to burgers and chicken wings. A real community hotspot.

$$
Pearl Club - Places, Products, People

Pearl Club may earn affiliate commissions from links on this site. Our editorial recommendations are independent.  Learn more in our FAQs

Places

CafesBakeriesBreakfastLunchDinnerBarsOutdoor DrinksArts & CultureMarketsStaysMore  Places

Cities

AustinBarcelonaBerlinLondonHelsinkiNew York CityLos AngelesSan FranciscoSanta BarbaraDublinMore  Cities

Products

Local GuidesFashionAccessoriesJewelryHome GoodsFoodWellnessTravel AccessoriesBooksStationaryMore  Products

Professionals

Travel AdvisorsInfluencersBloggersConferencesTravel AgenciesTourism BoardsTour OperatorsTech ProvidersTravel AssociationsIndustry ProfessionalsMore  Professionals

Curate

BlogBecome a CuratorWrite For UsClaim your Professional PageCreate your Professional PageAdd Hotel RecommendationsAdd a New PlaceAdd a New Product

Contact

FAQsAbout UsPartnershipsCareer OpeningsPearl Club for BusinessJoin our Community

Curate

BlogBecome a CuratorWrite For UsClaim your Professional PageCreate your Professional PageAdd Hotel RecommendationsAdd a New PlaceAdd a New Product

Contact

FAQsAbout UsPartnershipsCareer OpeningsPearl Club for BusinessJoin our Community
Connect with us
Pearl Club on InstagramPearl Club on FacebookPearl Club on DiscordPearl Club on LinkedInPearl Club on XPearl Club on Pinterest
Connect with us
Pearl Club on InstagramPearl Club on FacebookPearl Club on DiscordPearl Club on LinkedInPearl Club on XPearl Club on Pinterest

Pearl Club may earn affiliate commissions from links on this site. Our editorial recommendations are independent.  Learn more in our FAQs

General Service PoliciesTerms Of ServiceRefund PolicyPrivacy PolicyCalifornia NoticesSitemapsRecommendations© 2026 Tipsiti, LLC.
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Bayard's Ale House

2. Blind Barber, New York City

Blind Barber Bar

Barbershop by day, back-room cocktail bar by night - visit for the latter. Has a reputation for drawing a lively crowd. A unique bar and dance locale.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Blind Barber

3. La Milagrosa, New York City

Mezcaleria La Milagrosa

This speakeasy bar is hidden behind a laundromat 🧺 turned deli 🥪. They're known for the mezcal and good music. Sister to La Superior NYC.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about La Milagrosa

4. Bathtub Gin, New York City

Bathtub Gin Bar

Roaring-20's inspired speakeasy bar. Hidden behind a coffee shop, this bar is a call-back to the Prohibition era. An upmarket place for a date night, to see a Tuesday or Sunday night burlesque show, or to dance into the early hours.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Bathtub Gin

5. Blind Tiger Ale House, New York City

Blind Tiger Ale House Drink

A bonafide craft beer bar with an extensive brew menu. Also serves good pub-grub, like sandwiches and quesadillas. A worthy spot to sample beers and socialise whilst in Greenwich Village.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Blind Tiger Ale House

6. Radegast Hall and Biergarten, New York City

Radegast Interior

Williamsburg's rowdy beer hall with a regularly scheduled live brass band. People will be dancing on tables with beer and pretzels in hand. Plan on spending a lot of time here - it gets rowdy and you won't want to leave.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Radegast Hall and Biergarten

7. Jupiter Disco, New York City

Jupiter Disco - Party 1

Neon-drenched speakeasy meets outer space. Come for the retro, sci-fi vibe, and stay for the dance parties, creative drinks, and solid sound system. A smaller venue with a proven atmosphere.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Jupiter Disco

8. Twins Lounge, New York City

Twins Lounge upstairs is bright and cottage -like.

Two bars in one venue that feel like a vintage pool lounge and disco bar found in the Poconos rolled into one. No-fuss good drinks lounge. The upstairs is brighter and calmer- downstairs is a little more vivacious.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Twins Lounge

9. Lillie’s Victorian Establishment, New York City

Lillie’S Victorian Establishment Bottles

Stiff drinks in a bar inspired by the Victorian era gin palaces of England and Ireland. A quirky menu fits with the imported scotch and occasional art show. An eccentric dining and drinking venue dedicated to a historic socialite.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Lillie’s Victorian Establishment

10. Ponyboy, New York City

Interior of Ponyboy

North Brooklyn cocktail bar to underground disco to music hall to sushi – all in one place. Late-night gets really busy and you'll most likely wait in line. Pro tip: book a late-night reservation for some bites and stay for more dancing.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Ponyboy

11. The Spaniard, New York City

The Spaniard Burger

A horseshoe bar located in West Village that boasts a vintage New York vibe. They have a large whiskey offering, ample cocktails, and a standout burger. Reserve a booth for happy hour or dinner - or both.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about The Spaniard

12. The Wren, New York City

The Wren Cocktails

Intimate bar in Lower Manhattan. Grab a casual lunch or dinner here and pair it with their Wren-Quila cocktail. A great spot for 'Happy Hour' and a worthy place to start any bar crawl adventures.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about The Wren

13. The Lions Bar & Grill, New York City

a martini on a wooden bar top

Loud East Village corner bar pouring cold martinis and serving a signature dry-aged burger. The cramped, walk-in only room runs on 70s rock, with waits routinely stretching past an hour.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about The Lions Bar & Grill

14. schmuck., New York City

drinks, chips, and a menu on a table

Two-room cocktail spot with the feel of a lively house party, complete with vintage couches and a loud soundtrack. The highly technical, culinary-driven drinks are the main draw – expect combinations like strawberry with parmesan or fennel

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about schmuck.

15. The Long Hall Pub & Grocery, New York City

a pint of irish beer on a bar top

Long, wood-paneled pub in Murray Hill lined with shelves of imported Irish groceries. Locals pack the stools for early morning soccer matches and proper pints of Guinness.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about The Long Hall Pub & Grocery

16. Fáilte, New York City

a pint of guinness sitting on a table

Rough-hewn Kips Bay tavern warmed by a wood-burning fireplace. Pints of Guinness circulate among pool players and post-movie crowds from the theater across the street.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Fáilte

17. The Gem Saloon, New York City

a bar with stools and an american flag

Lively Murray Hill saloon built around a massive horseshoe bar. The room fills early for long weekday happy hours, then shifts to bottomless brunches, smash burgers, and late-night DJs on weekends.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about The Gem Saloon

18. Turtle Bay Tavern, New York City

three cocktails on a wooden table

Dimly lit sports tavern where locals watch the game from booths in the back. The kitchen serves smashed burgers and a BEC donut; the bar pours creative cocktails like the Irish Buck.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Turtle Bay Tavern

19. Bar Snack, New York City

a drink with ice and mint on top of a bar

Cozy, candlelit wine bar focused on natural French producers. The menu is tight and simple: just cheese, charcuterie, and other small plates designed to pair with a glass or two.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Bar Snack

20. Double Chicken Please, New York City

two colorful drinks on a table

Dual-concept cocktail bar where a back room serves drinks that taste like food – think Cold Pizza or Key Lime Pie. Its casual front room is for walk-ins, pouring tap cocktails and serving a standout hot honey fried chicken sandwich.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Double Chicken Please

21. Superbueno, New York City

a drink with ice cubes on a table

Vibrant East Village cocktail bar pairing inventive drinks with Mexican street food-style small plates. The neon-lit room stays packed and loud, running on a steady cumbia soundtrack and rounds of mushroom margaritas.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Superbueno

22. Mary O's, New York City

muffins on a cooling rack

Warm East Village pub pouring proper pints alongside weekly traditional Irish music sessions. Owner Mary O'Halloran works the floor, serving hearty shepherd's pie and fresh soda bread scones with Irish butter and blackberry jam.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Mary O's

23. Banzarbar, New York City

a cocktail on a bar with a bottle of gin next to it

Twenty-seat cocktail bar hidden above Freemans, styled like an early 20th-century explorer's tavern. Thematic drinks are complex and aromatic – a tasting menu pairs low-ABV cocktails with small plates of seafood.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Banzarbar

24. StEight(behind KUNIYA HAIR), New York City

a drink with ice on top of a marble counter

Japanese speakeasy hidden behind a hair salon – an intimate room with only a dozen seats. Bartenders pour rare sakes and handcrafted cocktails to a soundtrack of vinyl jazz.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about StEight(behind KUNIYA HAIR)

25. Swift Hibernian Lounge, New York City

a pint of irish beer on a wooden table

Classic NoHo Irish pub skipping the sports screens in favor of salvaged church pews, dark wood, and steady conversation. Bartenders pull proper pints of Guinness and pour from a deep whiskey list as the back room fills up.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Swift Hibernian Lounge

26. Molly's Shebeen Bar + Restaurant, New York City

a pint of guinness sitting on a wooden table

Gramercy pub with sawdust on the floor, low beamed ceilings, and a working wood-burning fireplace. Pints of Guinness and plates of shepherd's pie slide across the mahogany bar while sports play on the screens.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Molly's Shebeen Bar + Restaurant

27. Pig n Whistle, New York City

a bar with a variety of drinks on a wooden table

Midtown Irish pub and rugby stronghold opening as early as 6 a.m. for international matches. Dark oak paneling fills two floors busy with shepherd's pie and pints of Guinness.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Pig n Whistle

28. Paradise Lost, New York City

a room with couches and a chandelier

Maximalist East Village tiki bar channeling a tropical hellscape. Raucous surf punk fills the dark, cave-like room as elaborate cocktails arrive in custom demon mugs.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Paradise Lost

29. Bar Kabawa, New York City

a cocktail in a glass on a wooden table

Caribbean cocktail bar tucked into a quiet alley, pouring creative daiquiris and rum drinks from a rattan-fronted bar. The menu centers on West Indian patties; the soundtrack is high-energy and the custom paintings depict quiet island life.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Bar Kabawa

30. The Dead Rabbit, New York City

a cocktail on a bar top

Multi-level Financial District pub with a sawdust-floored tavern downstairs and a seated cocktail lounge above. Crowds pack the ground floor for Guinness and Irish coffee under a ceiling covered in stapled dollar bills.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about The Dead Rabbit

31. colbo next door, New York City

a room with a record player and a lamp

Lower East Side wine bar and listening room taking over a former dumpling factory. Couples share natural wine at the long concrete counter while custom wood speakers play high-fidelity vinyl against original stainless steel walls.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about colbo next door

32. Overstory, New York City

a cocktail with ice cubes in a glass

Intimate cocktail lounge atop an Art Deco skyscraper, wrapped by a terrace with 360-degree skyline views. The menu is spirit-forward and creative – think tequila Old Fashioneds and clarified milk punches with Earl Grey and champagne.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Overstory

33. Reception Bar, New York City

a martini with chocolate on a table

Minimalist bar crafting cocktails from soju infused with Korean botanicals – think white lotus and matcha. The intimate, peach-toned space also pours a full menu of non-alcoholic wellness elixirs.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Reception Bar

34. Spring (bar), New York City

three bottles of wine sitting on ice in a tray

Sleek Chinatown cocktail bar pouring surprising drinks and strong martinis. Most people come for the spacious backyard patio – the fried taro cake is the essential order.

$$
Bars icon
United States flagNYC
More about Spring (bar)

More Recommendations

Best Desserts in New York CityBest Midrange Bars in BerlinBest Midrange Bars in LondonBest Expensive Bars in New York CityBest Cheap Bars in New York CityBest Bars in Buenos AiresBest Midrange Cafes in New York CityBest Midrange Lunch Spots in New York CityBest Design Places in New York CityBest Bars in AustinBest Midrange Bakeries in New York CityBest Midrange Dinner Spots in New York City